Used Furniture Stores

10 Best Used Furniture Stores in Lafayette, IN

Jul 8, 2023
12 min read
10 Best Used Furniture Stores in Lafayette, IN

Welcome to Lafayette, Indiana - a place I call home and a city teeming with character and charm. Nestled within our community are hidden gems that make our town unique, including an array of used furniture stores waiting to be explored.

These stores, each with their own distinctive flair, hold a treasure trove of pre-loved pieces steeped in history and tradition. From vintage to contemporary, rustic to chic, Lafayette's range of used furniture stores is an adventure in and of itself. Ready to dive in? Let's embark on a journey to uncover the best used furniture stores our city has to offer.

The Joy of Discovering Treasures at Millie's Thrift Store

I have to admit, I have a knack for hunting down deals and hidden gems. So, when I first heard about Millie's Thrift Store, I was naturally excited. When I finally walked in, I was not disappointed. The store was expansive, housing a vast array of items, from clothing and toys to dishes and yard tools.

. The items were well-organized, which is not always the case in thrift stores. Prices? Reasonable, I must say. But the real cherry on top of the cake was their discount system. They use a color-coded tag system and depending on the day, you get the chance for a pretty hefty discount. I remember it being a day of blue and yellow tags, with a 50% and 75% discount respectively.

With three locations to choose from, Millie's Thrift Store offers a delightful experience of treasure hunting. The displays are well-lit, adding to the overall shopping experience. The staff was friendly and welcoming, always ready to help.

Another exciting part is the last Saturday of each month. It's almost like a festival with colors dropping their prices to as low as 90% off. Now, if you're someone like me who relishes a good bargain, you'll understand why this is a day you wouldn't want to miss.

Apart from the joy of shopping, Millie's also offers a great platform to donate your items. Be it your old bicycle, furniture, or metal cabinets, Millie's is more than happy to accept them.

To sum up, Millie's Thrift Store is more than just a thrift store; it's a community, a treasure trove, and a delight to visit. I guess I've found my new favorite spot for bargain hunting.

Millie’s Thrift Store · 101 Plaza Ln, Lafayette, IN 47909, United States
★★★★★ · Thrift store

Unbeatable Bargains at Lafayette Habitat ReStore

I can't even begin to describe the joy I felt walking out of the Lafayette Habitat ReStore, carrying two brand-new-looking upholstered arm chairs I got for a steal. It felt like I had just won the lottery - a home improvement lottery, that is!

These chairs weren't just any chairs. They were freshly reupholstered, in mint condition, and guess what? They were on sale for 50% off. Yes, you heard that right. I walked away with both chairs for a mere $10. A price tag that low might make you question the quality, but trust me, these chairs could easily have been showcased in any high-end furniture store. But instead, they were mine. All thanks to the incredible deals at Lafayette Habitat ReStore.

If you're in the market for quality and value, this place is a treasure trove. And it’s not just about the jaw-dropping bargains, the staff here is nothing short of amazing. They're friendly, knowledgeable and help make the entire shopping experience nothing less than a pleasure. It's no wonder the Lafayette Habitat ReStore has become my favorite store in town. Can't wait for my next visit!

Lafayette Habitat ReStore · 3815 Fortune Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States
★★★★★ · Building materials store

Discovering Hidden Gems at Twice As Nice Ladies Consignment Boutique

Strolling down the streets of Lafayette, I found myself in front of Twice As Nice Ladies Consignment Boutique, a local treasure that has drawn me in time and time again. The boutique specializes in fall and winter clothing until March, and I must admit, their collection never fails to impress. Each time I visit, it's like opening a trove of brand-new items, but without the hefty price tags. The affordability of the high-quality items is what keeps me coming back.

Recently, the collection at Twice As Nice has been nothing short of spectacular. As I peruse the racks, I always find myself captivated by hidden gems that make me wonder how I ever managed without them. My friends, too, have been quite taken with the remarkable quality of clothing the store offers. Our shopping trips to Twice As Nice have morphed into a beloved ritual, a testament to the allure of this boutique.

Twice As Nice Ladies Consignment Boutique · 738 S Earl Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904, United States
★★★★★ · Consignment shop

A Trip Down Memory Lane at Leaping Leopard Antiques

When the weekend comes, there's no place I'd rather browse than Leaping Leopard Antiques. With a vast range of items, from vintage furniture and home decor to antique kitchen supplies, this store is a treasure trove waiting to be explored.

Every visit feels like a step back in time, the well-organized collections and clean presentation making for an enjoyable shopping experience. Whether you're hunting for a unique piece to complete your home or just looking to while away an afternoon, you'll never be disappointed. And if you happen to fall in love with a piece of furniture, the staff is always on hand to help you load it into your car.

If there's one thing that really sets Leaping Leopard Antiques apart for me, it's the quality of the items. On a recent trip with my wife, we were both amazed by the mint condition of the antiques. It felt like we were taking a stroll through a well-preserved past rather than just shopping.

But be warned, the treasures in this store come at a price. The items can range from comparatively affordable to quite pricey. However, every once in a while, you might stumble upon a good deal. Like the time my husband found a comic book that was a steal.

Leaping Leopard Antiques remains a favorite spot for my wife and me. It's a place where we can enjoy our love for the old and beautiful, and we can't wait for our next visit.

Leaping Leopard Antiques · 2145 S 4th St, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store


There's a certain thrill that comes with discovering a hidden gem in your own neighborhood! If you're anything like me, you love the thrill of the hunt and there's no place better for treasure hunting than Sell It Here located in Lafayette, Indiana.

Over the years, I've found countless unique pieces to decorate my home from the multitude of vendors showcasing a fascinating array of items. From vintage furniture to quirky trinkets, there's always something new and exciting to discover. Each visit feels like a fresh adventure and I can honestly say that a large part of my home owes its distinct charm to these fantastic finds.

But it's not just the products that make Sell-It-Here such a delightful place. The store itself is immaculately maintained, always clean and inviting. The staff, too, contribute to the pleasant atmosphere. They're always ready to lend a helping hand, guiding you to your desired items and answering all your queries with a smile on their face.

Sell It Here · 3805 Fortune Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States
★★★★☆ · Flea market

Discovering Treasures at Reclaimed Hope

Walking into Reclaimed Hope is like stepping into a trove of beautiful treasures. Located right here in our very own neighborhood, this quaint little thrift store has become my favorite place to find unique pieces of jewelry. Its charm is not just limited to the beautiful merchandise it sells, but can be felt through its immaculate and beautifully decorated interiors as well.

Each visit to Reclaimed Hope is like embarking on a treasure hunt where I stumble upon beautiful trinkets, vintage items, wall art, and even an assortment of books, CDs, DVDs, and succulents. It is safe to say that I've found some of my most cherished items here - a vintage necklace that always receives compliments and a beautifully painted dish that now embellishes my coffee table, to name a few.

However, what makes Reclaimed Hope most special to me is the noble cause it stands for. All the proceeds from the store go towards the Vision of Hope, a ministry program dedicated to helping women in domestic violence situations. It gives me immense satisfaction knowing that my purchases are not just fulfilling my love for thrift shopping, but also contributing towards an important cause. The fact that many of the items are handcrafted by the ladies in the program adds a personal touch to every purchase I make.

There's also an added bonus for thrift shoppers and foodies alike - the Northend Cafe, recently opened right next to Reclaimed Hope. Offering delicious breakfast and lunch daily, it's the perfect place to grab a bite after a fulfilling shopping experience.

Reclaimed Hope · 2000 Elmwood Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904, United States
★★★★☆ · Thrift store

Discovering Merrell's Furniture 1

When it comes to furnishing your home, you want to find a place that combines quality, affordability, and exceptional customer service. That's why I was thrilled to stumble upon Merrell's Furniture 1. It was like unearthing a hidden gem in my own backyard.

From the moment I walked through the doors, I was greeted with nothing but patience and kindness. The staff were not just there to make a sale, but genuinely intent on assisting me in finding the perfect pieces for my home. They guided me through their vast selection with a smile, never rushing me, and providing insightful suggestions when needed.

The day I bought my dining table was a memorable one. The delivery was swift and the delivery person was the epitome of professionalism. I was pleasantly surprised when I realized the delivery was the same day. A memorable first meal at our new table was enjoyed, thanks to the efficiency of Merrell's Furniture 1.

The quality of their merchandise is outstanding. Every piece I have bought, including that amazing table, has been durable and stylish, enriching the aesthetics of my home. Their affordable prices are just the cherry on top.

I've become quite a regular at Merrell's Furniture 1. It's become a ritual to check their Facebook updates for any new inventory. And truth be told, I've become a bit of a furniture shopping addict, thanks to the wonderful experience at Merrell's.

So, if you're looking to spruce up your home with some fantastic furniture, I wholeheartedly recommend visiting Merrell's Furniture 1. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

Merrell’s Furniture 1 · 3501 Union St, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States
★★★★☆ · Furniture store

Discovering Hidden Treasures at Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store

Every town has its own hidden gem, and for us in Lafayette, that gem is the Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store. I always look forward to popping in every week or so to see what new treasures I can find. You never know what you might stumble upon - antique furniture, vintage clothes, quirky home decor, or even just some everyday household items. The selection is constantly changing, so there's always something new to discover.

The staff at the Trinity Life Ministry store are genuinely some of the friendliest people you'll meet in town. Even during the busiest times, they always have a smile on their face and are ready to help. Over time, they've almost become like family, always greeting me by name and always ready for a chat.

While the prices can sometimes be on the higher side, especially for certain items, I've found that the quality of the goods justify the cost. And the best part is knowing that every penny I spend is going towards supporting a great cause. The store is an integral part of the Trinity Life Ministry's efforts to combat addiction in our community. Every purchase helps fund their programs and services.

If you're in the neighborhood, I highly recommend dropping by the Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store. Whether you're hunting for a unique find or just want to support a local cause, it's definitely worth a visit. Remember to bring a big bag - you'll need it for all the great finds you'll come across!

Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store · 2324 Shoshone Ct, Lafayette, IN 47904, United States
★★★★☆ · Thrift store

Discovering Delights at Star Furniture

I remember the day I stumbled upon a hidden gem in the heart of my city, a showroom that goes by the name of Star Furniture. It was as if I had stepped into an Aladdin's cave, with everything from traditional furniture that whispered stories of the past, to contemporary designs that boldly declared the future. And the surprises didn't stop at furniture. There were mattresses that promised dreams sweeter than honey, and home accents that seemed to have been crafted by artists rather than machines.

The first time I walked in, I was searching for a new dining table to replace the rickety old one in our kitchen. I remember being amazed by the variety of options and their affordability. What I bought was not just a table, but a well-made piece of craftsmanship that was easy to assemble and instantly elevated the style and comfort of our home. I was truly impressed by the quality of the item, especially considering its reasonable price.

Since then, Star Furniture has become my go-to place for all my home furnishing needs. Their extensive in-store collection never fails to inspire me, and the sales associates are always ready to provide genuine, informative assistance. On one such occasion, an unforgettable sales lady named Sam guided us through our shopping with patience and expertise, answering our questions and helping us make the best choice from the available options. Her pleasant demeanor and knowledge truly enhanced our shopping experience and convinced us to return in the future.

Star Furniture is not just a store, it's a treasure trove for anyone looking to beautify their living spaces without breaking the bank. So, if you're ever in the neighborhood and in need of a new furniture set for your living room, don't hesitate to drop by. You might just find exactly what you're looking for, and much more!

Star Furniture · 3812 Fortune Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States
★★★★☆ · Furniture store

Hunting for Treasures at Goodwill Store

There's a certain charm that accompanies a trip to The Goodwill Store - a sense of adventure permeates the air as you never know what hidden treasures you might stumble upon. Located at, it's a spot that always brings a sense of nostalgia. The store is filled with pre-owned clothing, furniture, housewares and so much more. It's almost like stepping into a wonderland of forgotten items just waiting to be rediscovered.

The thrill of the hunt and the prospect of unearthing a hidden gem keeps me coming back. As they say, one man's trash is another man's treasure, and at Goodwill, treasures abound.

Goodwill Store · 3229 Daugherty Dr, Lafayette, IN 47909, United States
★★★★☆ · Thrift store

In wrapping up, I find myself constantly amazed by the variety and quality of used furniture stores here in Lafayette, Indiana. From the wonderful finds at Millie's Thrift Store to the hidden treasures in Leaping Leopard Antiques, there's always something unique and affordable to discover. It's also incredible to see the community-focused efforts of places like Lafayette Habitat ReStore and the Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store. Whether I'm seeking to upgrade my home decor, find a vintage piece, or just take a leisurely stroll through aisles filled with history and charm, there's always a store in town ready to satisfy my needs.