8 Best Used Furniture Stores in Youngstown, OH

Aug 22, 2023
10 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Youngstown, OH

As a resident of Youngstown, let me take you on a journey through some of the most interesting and unique used furniture stores in our city. Youngstown, OH, is a place rich with hidden gems where you can find everything from modern, stylish pieces to vintage treasures.

Whether you're looking for a statement piece to complete your living room or a special item that brings back memories, these stores offer a wide variety of options to fit every taste and budget. Get ready to explore and find your next favorite piece of furniture.

A Treasure Hunt at Rite Choice Thrift Store

Rite Choice Thrift Store · 104 Gluck St Apt D, Youngstown, OH 44505, United States
Discount store

One of my favorite places to explore in Youngstown is the Rite Choice Thrift Store. It’s a place filled with stories, each item holding a piece of history. From antique furniture and lighting fixtures to vintage jewelry and tools, it's a treasure trove that never fails to intrigue me. The store may not be huge, but the wide variety of merchandise it holds makes it feel like a labyrinth of curiosities.

The shopkeeper, affectionately known as Tony in the local community, is as much a part of the appeal as the goods themselves. He's always friendly and welcoming, eager to share the tales behind the trinkets. His knowledge is extensive, and he's always willing to help you find that unique piece to add to your collection.

Whether I'm looking for a unique piece to add to my collection or simply seeking a few minutes of peaceful browsing, Rite Choice Thrift Store never disappoints. It's a quaint oasis of the past tucked away in our bustling city of Youngstown. The next time you're in the mood for a little treasure hunting, I recommend giving Rite Choice Thrift Store a visit.

A Lifesaver in Disguise: Rent-A-Center

Rent-A-Center · 2625 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44507, United States
★★★★☆ · Furniture store

There’s a place in Youngstown that is a lifesaver in disguise; it's called Rent-A-Center. I have relied on Rent-A-Center for years now. From a computer to a love seat, and currently a sectional and a washer/dryer set, I've rented and eventually paid off a range of items over the years, each one enhancing my home and lifestyle.

One thing's for sure, the staff at Rent-A-Center are truly awesome. I've had a few issues over time, but most of them were promptly resolved. What impresses me most about this store is their commitment to service. Despite the pricing being a bit on the higher side (a Playstation 5 here costs over $2000 compared to $559 at Best Buy), the service and staff make it worthwhile.

There was this one time when I was out of town due to a family emergency and they patiently waited in my driveway for over an hour. Their understanding and patience in such a situation were commendable. I've also had them visit my place of employment to sort out issues, which I found to be extremely convenient.

In short, Rent-A-Center has been my go-to place for furniture and appliance rental in Youngstown. Despite the occasional hiccup, they've always managed to make the experience worthwhile with their service and staff. If you're in a pinch and need furniture or appliances quickly, I’d recommend giving Rent-A-Center a shot.

Indianola Furniture

Indianola Furniture · 1405 E Indianola Ave, Youngstown, OH 44502, United States
★★★★☆ · Used furniture store

After a good experience at Rent-A-Center, I decided to explore some more and found myself at Indianola Furniture. The store, found here on Google maps, is a treasure trove of furniture waiting to be discovered. It was like stepping into an Aladdin's cave, with every nook and cranny filled with furniture of all kinds. I was on the lookout for a recliner, but alas, they were out of them that day.

However, the absence of a recliner didn't dampen my spirits. The store had a plethora of other enticing pieces that had me hooked. A carved mahogany headboard and baseboard caught my eye, exuding an air of elegance and sophistication. The store was neatly organized despite the multitude of items, and I could see it being an ideal place for anyone looking to furnish their first apartment or a new home. The prices were reasonable and the variety was astounding.

The gentleman who helped me around the store, possibly the owner, was friendly and well-informed about the items in the store. His knowledge and passion for the furniture were evident, which made the browsing experience all the more enjoyable. Even though I didn't find the recliner I was looking for, the visit to Indianola Furniture was worth it. I plan to revisit the store regularly, keeping an eye out for any new pieces that might catch my fancy. The store left such an impression on me that I can see myself becoming a regular customer.

Yankee Trading Post

Yankee Trading Post · 3313 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44509, United States
★★★★☆ · Thrift store

The thrill of the hunt has a whole new meaning at the Yankee Trading Post. This place is not just a store, but a journey through various epochs of furniture design. The first time I walked into the store, I immediately felt the diversity and richness of the collection. It was a treasure trove of mostly vintage and some modern pieces.

The prices were more than fair and the lady who was working that day was incredibly cordial. She was not just an employee, but a guide who walked me through the different eras represented in the store. Her knowledge about the furniture was impressive and she was extremely helpful. This personal touch made my shopping experience exceptional.

What struck me about the Yankee Trading Post was the quality of the pieces. I found some fantastic cherry bedroom sets, a gorgeous walnut dining room set, and a beautiful mahogany dining room set, all in excellent condition and reasonably priced. The store's owner also offers furniture restoration services, which I found to be a great advantage. On one occasion, I fell in love with a piece that needed minor repairs, and the owner gave me a quote for the work before I purchased it.

The Yankee Trading Post is much more than a used furniture store. It's a place where furniture gets a second chance and customers get to own unique pieces that tell a story. Every visit is a new adventure, and I can't wait for my next one.

Discover the Charm at Market Street Furniture & Appliances

Market Street Furniture & Appliances · 3917 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512, United States
★★★★☆ · Furniture store

Upon entering Market Street Furniture & Appliances, I was immediately greeted with warm smiles and a friendly attitude. The staff was incredibly helpful and courteous, guiding me around the store with enthusiasm. Their wide assortment of furniture and appliances had everything I needed to furnish my entire home, from the living room to the kitchen. The prices were very reasonable, a pleasant surprise for such quality items.

The store itself was impressively clean and well-organized. It was easy to navigate through the large inventory, and every piece of furniture was displayed in a way that you could imagine it in your own home. I loved my purchases and couldn’t help but be excited for my next visit.

Perhaps what struck me most about Market Street Furniture & Appliances was their commitment to customer satisfaction. When I faced an issue with an appliance I had brought home, they were quick to offer assistance and find a solution, a testament to their dedication to ensuring a positive customer experience.

Market Street Furniture & Appliances is a jewel in Youngstown, OH. Whether you're looking for a new dining set or a reliable appliance, this is the place to go. The quality of their products and their exceptional customer service never fail to impress. It's no surprise that this place has become my go-to for all my furniture and appliance needs.

Economy Furniture

Economy Furniture · 2828 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44507, United States
★★★★☆ · Used appliance store

Stepping into Economy Furniture is like stepping into a treasure trove of quality furniture and appliances. The staff there are not just salespeople, they're terrific guides, always ready to help you navigate through their wide array of options. The prices are very reasonable too, making it the ideal place for anyone, whether you're setting up a new home or just in need of a few pieces.

I've been everywhere looking for everything, and I can confidently say that this establishment is one of the two best in town that I've found. They have everything you could possibly need for your house - appliances, mattresses, bedroom sets, living room sets, all at unbelievable prices. The quality of their products is simply unmatched, and their service is top-notch.

I can't stress enough how highly I recommend Economy Furniture. It's the only place I'll be shopping when I need furniture or appliances in the future. If you're in Youngstown, do yourself a favor and pay them a visit. You won't be disappointed.

Eclectic Furniture

Eclectic Furniture · 2736 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44507, United States
★★★★☆ · Used furniture store

A stone's throw away from Economy Furniture is another gem, the Eclectic Furniture store. This place is a treasure trove for those who appreciate a mix of different styles and periods in their furniture. One Saturday, although the store was technically closed, I ran into the owner, John. A very kind gentleman, he allowed me to look around, and I was not disappointed. The collection is fascinating, with a plethora of truly unique pieces.

The store has an impressive selection of renowned brands like Drexel, Henredon, Pennsylvania House, Harden, and Ethan Allen. But what caught my eye were the French antiques and the wide array of other vintage furniture. I couldn't help but admire the fantastic cherry bedroom sets, the gorgeous walnut dining room set, and the beautiful mahogany dining room set.

What sets Eclectic Furniture apart is that the owner also runs a furniture restoration business. So, if you find a piece that needs a bit of TLC, he can give you a quote for any repairs before you buy. This service is gold for someone like me who loves restoring old furniture to its former glory.

Even though some items might seem a bit overpriced, trust me, the quality and uniqueness of these pieces make them well worth the investment. If you're looking for a one-of-a-kind piece to add character to your space, you should definitely check out Eclectic Furniture.

A Vintage Wonderland at Greyland Vintage

Greyland Vintage · 23w W Boardman St, Youngstown, OH 44503, United States
★★★★★ · Vintage clothing store

Walking into Greyland Vintage is like stepping into a time capsule. This unique store, tucked away in Youngstown, is like a treasure trove of nostalgia. I remember my first visit vividly - I was instantly struck by the epic setup, which felt like I had been transported to a cozy, vintage home.

I was drawn in by the impressive vinyl and art collections, each piece more intriguing than the last. The collection is so extensive and carefully curated, it feels like you're exploring someone's personal gallery. The owner, Todd, is friendly and eager to share his knowledge about each piece, making the shopping experience even more enjoyable.

The prices at Greyland Vintage are surprisingly reasonable for such unique finds. There's something here for every budget, from pocket-change treasures to more significant investment pieces. It's refreshing to find a vintage store that doesn't overcharge for the simple pleasure of owning a piece of history.

But what truly sets Greyland Vintage apart from other used furniture stores is its commitment to the local community. They host open mic nights and other local events, creating a vibrant and welcoming space for everyone. I can't wait to bring my friends here next time. Trust me, if you're in Youngstown, don't miss out on the experience at Greyland Vintage.

Wrapping Up the Thrift Adventure

After exploring the best used furniture stores in Youngstown, OH, it's apparent that this city has a rich and diverse selection of thrift stores with an array of unique, quality furniture.

From the high-end vintage pieces at Ms. Charolette's "Resale" Boutique to the affordable finds at the Yankee Trading Post, there's a store to suit everyone's style and budget. Next time you're in the city, don't miss the chance to explore these thrift stores - you never know what you might find! Happy thrifting!