Used Furniture Stores

9 Best Used Furniture Stores in Sarasota, FL

Aug 4, 2023
11 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Sarasota, FL

When it comes to finding unique, high-quality used furniture, Sarasota, Florida is a treasure trove. The city is home to an array of furniture stores that offer an eclectic mix of pieces, from vintage finds to modern gems.

Whether you're a seasoned bargain hunter or just looking for that perfect piece to complete your home, these used furniture stores in Sarasota are worth exploring. Get ready to discover some hidden gems and revamp your living space with one-of-a-kind pieces that tell a story.

This article compiles the shared experiences and reviews of our readers who have had encounters with various used furniture stores in the city. While it highlights some of the top-rated stores based on our readers' personal experiences, it's important to remember that this list is not exhaustive. There is a wealth of used furniture stores in the city that haven't been featured but are certainly worth exploring. We encourage you to use this article as a starting point, and to venture out and discover the many other excellent options available to you!

Sarasota Trading Co

Sarasota Trading Co · 522 S Pineapple Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
★★★★☆ · Antique store

Stepping into the Sarasota Trading Co was like stepping into a different era. The first time I visited was years back, and it had more of a quaint antique shop vibe. But on my recent visit, I was pleasantly surprised to find that it had transformed into something akin to a high-value antique auction shop.

The store was brimming with exquisite items, each more beautiful than the last, and the pricing was reasonable, which made the shopping experience even more delightful.The store was home to a myriad of interesting pieces, and each corner held a new surprise. It was a joy to navigate through the array of beautiful items, from small trinkets to large furniture pieces.

I couldn't help but admire the quality of the antiques, each piece seemed to have its own story to tell. The transformation of the Sarasota Trading Co from a simple antique shop to an antique auction house is a testament to their commitment to offering only the best to their customers. I’m definitely glad the shop is still around and I got to visit again. If you're a lover of unique and high-quality antiques, you must visit the Sarasota Trading Co.

A Treasure Trove at Bentley Crest Estate Buyers

Bentley Crest Estate Buyers · 2200 Floyd St, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States
Antique store

My quest for unique pieces led me to Bentley Crest Estate Buyers, a haven for antique lovers. This quaint place is brimming with wide variety of merchandise that tells a story. From antique furniture and lighting fixtures to vintage jewelry and tools, I found myself enchanted by the endless variety.

The shopkeeper, Tony, is a treasure himself. Just as captivating as the goods themselves, Tony is always friendly and welcoming, ready to share the tales behind the trinkets. His extensive knowledge added an extra layer of charm to my shopping experience. Whether I was looking for a unique piece to add to my collection or simply indulging in some peaceful browsing, Bentley Crest Estate Buyers never disappointed.

This place is a quaint oasis of the past, filled with treasures waiting to be discovered. If you are looking for a shopping experience that takes you back in time and offers a unique selection, Bentley Crest Estate Buyers is the place to visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

Vintage Key

Vintage Key · 1175 N Washington Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

Journeying to the Venice Mercato, I stumbled upon a one-of-a-kind treasure trove - Vintage Key. This charming store, curated by Ellen, is an exquisite blend of modern elements and the natural world. As I walked around, I found myself completely engrossed in the beautifully selected items that lined the shelves.

For a New Yorker like me, transforming my bedroom into a tranquil oasis was a long-cherished dream. At Vintage Key, I found the perfect pieces to make that dream come true. The best part? Ellen went the extra mile to figure out the most cost-effective shipping options for me, packaged my purchases carefully, and had them delivered to Upstate NY in record time.

With each visit, I find myself in awe of Ellen's eye for design and her ability to create beautiful, multi-layered collections. My recent acquisition, a stunning mid-century modern desk and chair set, has added a touch of character to my home office, making it a space I truly enjoy working in.

For anyone in Sarasota looking to infuse their home decor with unique touches, I highly recommend a visit to Vintage Key. The variety of items and exceptional customer service guarantee a shopping experience unlike any other. With each visit, I find myself eagerly looking forward to my next, excited to see what Ellen has stocked for my next trip.

The Sarasota Collection Home Store

The Sarasota Collection Home Store · 622 Central Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

The first time I walked into The Sarasota Collection Home Store, I was taken aback by the stylish, upscale furniture and accessories that filled the showroom. It was clear that this wasn't just a furniture store, but a haven for anyone with a taste for fine design. From home to patio, each piece was more stunning than the last.

The owners, Marcus and Pam Anast, along with their team, Jamie and Jan, made my shopping experience seamless. They were friendly, knowledgeable, and their expertise in interior design and contemporary furniture was evident in their carefully curated collection. Their prices were great and their customer service was off the charts, making me feel like I was their most valued customer.

Marcus and his team were especially helpful when I was new to the area. They welcomed me with open arms, assisting me in transforming my new house into a home. From furniture to rugs to lighting, they had everything I needed and more. They even helped me find specific pieces that were not currently in their showroom.

One thing I particularly love about The Sarasota Collection Home Store is their approach to design. They listen to your needs and then help you put everything together to create a space that truly reflects your taste. Whether I was just browsing or making a purchase, they always made me feel welcomed and appreciated.

In the world of high-end furniture stores, The Sarasota Collection Home Store stands out with its beautiful showroom, talented design team, and excellent customer service. It's more than just a store, it's a shopping experience that leaves you looking forward to your next visit.

McCormack & Company

McCormack & Company · 500 S Pineapple Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store

Walking into McCormack & Company feels like stepping back in time to vintage heaven. The owner, Tony, is not only kind but also extremely knowledgeable. His amazing inventory is a true reflection of his expertise. If you're looking for hard-to-find pieces from Knoll, Herman Miller, Eames, and more, this is the place to be.

With every visit, I find myself in awe of the unique gems that this shop offers. On my last trip, I was particularly impressed by the range of collectibles available at reasonable prices. Tony was always there to provide insights and answer any questions I had.

What sets McCormack & Company apart from others is the carefully curated collection of spectacular and unique modern pieces. Each visit feels like a new adventure, and I always find myself looking forward to the next one. With its exceptional service and amazing collection, McCormack & Company has quickly become one of my favorite places to shop for unique furniture pieces in Sarasota.

A Hidden Gem: Unique and Chic

Unique and Chic · 2115 Siesta Dr, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

If you're a fan of one-of-a-kind pieces that truly stand out, then your next stop has to be Unique and Chic. Nestled in Sarasota, this furniture haven is a dream come true for lovers of all things vintage and unique. The moment I stepped into the store, I was greeted by an array of stunning furniture pieces, each with its own unique charm and character.

The owner, Jaime, is an artist in her own right. I watched in awe as she transformed a simple console into a work of art. The vibrant colors and intricate detailing were simply breathtaking, and the piece became an instant conversation starter in my home. Jaime's workmanship was flawless, and the final product was truly a testament to her talent and creativity.

What truly sets Unique and Chic apart, though, is the customer service. Jamie was incredibly helpful, guiding me through the store and helping me pick out pieces that would suit my home decor style. She even went the extra mile to deliver my furniture at a reasonable price, making the entire shopping experience a delight.

But the store is more than just a furniture shop. It's a treasure trove of home decor accents, dishes, and more, making it an absolute must-visit if you're in the area. I've been a regular customer for over six months now, and I can honestly say that I've never been disappointed. Whether you're looking for a vintage piece to complete your living room, or just want to browse and soak in the ambiance, Unique and Chic is a gem of a place that should definitely be on your list.

Discover the Hidden Gems at Scavengers Marketplace SRQ

Scavengers Marketplace SRQ · 1175 N Washington Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34237, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

In my quest for unique home decor, I stumbled upon the Scavengers Marketplace SRQ. My eyes were immediately greeted by a vast selection of indoor and outdoor decor and furniture. What struck me the most was how all the items were tastefully displayed in themed sections, making it easy to envision how they would fit into my home.

Each time I visit, I'm impressed by the uniqueness of every crafter's selection. It's a place that certainly demands your time and attention. I've found it hard to leave without a few treasured finds. My personal favorite was a quirky lizard wall hanging that now adds a touch of whimsy to my living room.

The marketplace isn’t just limited to decor; they have a little bit of everything. From antique to modern, contemporary and beach decor, it's a place that caters to diverse tastes. I was particularly drawn to their collection of furniture, baskets, vases, and artwork. Whether you're looking to decorate your home or just appreciate the beauty of well-crafted items, Scavengers Marketplace SRQ is a must-visit.

So, if you're in Sarasota and have a love for all things unique, make sure to pay a visit to the Scavengers Marketplace SRQ. Trust me; you won’t be disappointed.

Step Back in Time at Dawson's Vintage and More

Dawson’s Vintage and More · 1342 Central Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store

The moment I stepped into Dawson's Vintage and More, it felt like I had taken a step back in time. The place was filled with all sorts of fascinating items, a treasure trove of memories and stories waiting to be discovered. The atmosphere was slightly warm, but that didn't deter me from exploring the nooks and crannies of the store, each corner revealing more intriguing finds.

The store's owner was incredibly friendly and hospitable, making the browsing experience even more enjoyable. I was touched by his dedication to preserving these antique items, each of which held a piece of history and a touch of nostalgia. The best part? The prices were surprisingly affordable, making it easy to support this local business.

If you're the type to find joy in nostalgia and love the thrill of digging through piles of vintage items, you'll feel right at home here. Dawson's Vintage and More isn't just a store; it's a haven for antique lovers and a testament to the beauty of the past. Whether you're on the hunt for a specific item or just want to spend a day reminiscing about the good old days, this is the place to be.

A Nostalgic Journey at Malu's Vintage Unique Finds

Malu’s Vintage Unique Finds · 2495 12th St, Sarasota, FL 34237, United States
★★★★★ · Antique furniture store

Stepping into Malu's Vintage Unique Finds is like opening a treasure chest filled with hidden gems. It's always a joy to discover the unique items in this shop. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by Marjorie, the kind and talented owner who has an eye for tasteful decor and vintage items.

Every visit to Malu's is a delight. I can't help but leave with something special every time. The variety of items is impressive, and the reasonable pricing means I always get great value for my money. From vintage lamps and candles to one-of-a-kind decorative pieces, Malu's truly has the best selection I've seen in and outside of Sarasota.

I remember buying a piece of furniture that has since become a conversation starter in my home. It's not just the item itself that's unique but also the story behind it. The compliments I receive about it are a testament to Malu's exquisite taste.

But the best part of my shopping experience at Malu's Vintage Unique Finds is the owner herself. Malu is so creative, artistic, and fun to talk to. She lets you shop at your own pace, and her passion for vintage items shines through in every corner of her shop.

If you're in Sarasota and have a love for unique vintage finds, do pay a visit to Malu's Vintage Unique Finds. It's my favorite, and I bet it will be yours too.


There is something incredibly satisfying about finding a piece of furniture that has a story to tell. It's like unearthing a hidden treasure that can add charm and character to your home. Sarasota, with its plethora of used furniture stores, has been my playground in this regard.

Whether you are on a tight budget, looking for something unique, or simply enjoy the thrill of the hunt, these stores offer an array of options that cater to different tastes and budgets. From modern minimalist designs at Soft Square to vintage and antique pieces at The Sarasota Collection Home Store, the variety is truly astounding.

The joy of shopping for used furniture is that no two visits to a store are the same. The inventory is constantly changing, and you never quite know what you might come across on any given day. It's this sense of adventure and excitement that keeps me coming back.

So, the next time you're in Sarasota and in the mood to hunt for some second-hand gems, do consider exploring these stores. Remember, it's not just about the furniture, it's about the experience and the stories that come with it. Happy hunting!