Used Furniture Stores

9 Best Used Furniture Stores in Manhattan, NYC

Aug 3, 2023
12 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Manhattan, NY

Welcome to the ultimate guide to used furniture stores in Manhattan, New York! As a resident and furniture enthusiast, I've had the privilege of exploring some of the best vintage and second-hand furniture stores that the city has to offer.

From hidden thrift shops to high-end consignment stores, Manhattan is a treasure trove for unique, affordable and quality pieces. Whether you're setting up a new home or sprucing up your existing space, these stores offer a sustainable and economical way to furnish your home with character and style. So, let's dive in and discover the charm and variety of used furniture stores in Manhattan, NY!

This article compiles the shared experiences and reviews of our readers who have had encounters with various used furniture stores in the city. While it highlights some of the top-rated stores based on our readers' personal experiences, it's important to remember that this list is not exhaustive. There is a wealth of used furniture stores in the city that haven't been featured but are certainly worth exploring. We encourage you to use this article as a starting point, and to venture out and discover the many other excellent options available to you!

Furnish Green

Furnish Green · 132 1/2 W 24th St, New York, NY 10011, United States
★★★★★ · Antique furniture store

Right in the heart of Manhattan, I stumbled upon a hidden gem, a one-stop shop for vintage and antique furniture enthusiasts - Furnish Green. My first visit to the store was completely unplanned. My daughter and her friends had recently moved to the city, and we ended up at Furnish Green while looking for unique pieces to furnish their new space.

I was taken aback by the range of items available. From one-of-a-kind lighting fixtures to beautifully restored vintage furniture, the inventory was quite impressive. The best part? New items were added daily, so every visit felt like a fresh experience.

The prices were the cherry on top. Considering the quality and uniqueness of the items, the affordability was a pleasant surprise. But what really set Furnish Green apart was their staff. They were beyond compare. Helpful, knowledgeable, and patient, they made the shopping experience enjoyable rather than overwhelming.

Moving items in a big city is not the easiest of tasks, but the staff at Furnish Green made it seamless. They recommended a mover they work with regularly, and he was fantastic.

My subsequent visits to Furnish Green were just as fulfilling. I found some incredible vintage pieces like a tulip lamp and hanging lighting fixture that added a unique charm to my space.

If you're ever in Manhattan and are looking for places to shop for vintage and antique furniture, I'd highly recommend Furnish Green. It's a place I visit again and again, and I'm sure you'll do the same once you experience it.

A Gem in the City: Kaiyo

Kaiyo · Headquarters, 50 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10010, United States
★★★★☆ · Corporate office

The city that never sleeps also never disappoints when it comes to shopping. On one of my furniture hunting trips, I found myself at Kaiyo. This isn't your average furniture store, it's a treasure trove of gently used major brand pieces, perfect for those looking for quality within a budget.

I was initially shopping for a sofa, and my luck turned when I found a beautifully designed one along with an ottoman at Kaiyo. The price was surprisingly satisfying for a major brand, gently used sofa set.

What made my experience even more pleasant was the professional delivery service by Raymond A. and Chi. They were courteous, arrived within the promised time, and even took the extra effort to wear shoe covers, respecting my newly moved-in home.

The furniture came wrapped in blankets, ensuring they were cushioned and protected. What surprised me even more was the condition of the pieces. They were in an even better condition than I expected for something gently used! I couldn't have been happier with my finds.

On a different visit, I found a beautiful table that was almost in new condition. It was a unique piece that I wouldn't have been able to afford if it was brand new. Shane and Eliseo, the delivery guys, were terrific! They allowed me to fully examine the table and even helped me extend it.

Kaiyo isn't just a furniture store for me now; it's a place where I know I can find quality pieces that add personality to my home, come in good condition, and are delivered with excellent service. It's an added bonus that by purchasing from Kaiyo, I'm supporting sustainability by buying used furniture.

So, whether you've just moved into a new home or are looking to refresh your space, I'd highly recommend checking out Kaiyo. Trust me, you'll be telling everyone about it, just like I am.

Small Furniture

Small Furniture · 109 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture repair shop

Walking through the neighborhood, I came across a gem of a place called Small Furniture. The name may be unassuming, but the shop is a treasure trove of incredible and affordable pieces of furniture. I was immediately drawn into the store by the unique and varied pieces on display.

The owner, Bob, is a fixture in the neighborhood and his workmanship on repairs is simply incredible. One of the pieces I own from his shop is a point of pride in my home. Every time I look at it, I'm reminded of the craftsmanship and care that went into it.

Visiting Small Furniture became a part of my daily routine, especially during those early days with my new baby. The store has a warm, welcoming vibe that made it feel like a little home away from home.

What makes Small Furniture stand out is the shopping experience. It's genuinely one of the nicest I've ever had. Bob is exceptionally kind, helpful, and very knowledgeable about antique furniture. Whether you're a first-time buyer or a seasoned collector, you're guaranteed to find something that catches your eye at Small Furniture.

So the next time you find yourself in Manhattan, do yourself a favor and stop by Small Furniture. You'll be glad you did.

A Love Affair with Lovesac

Lovesac · 230 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

Sitting in a Lovesac is like sinking into a cloud – a truly unique and comfortable experience. This chain retailer, known for its large, foam-filled beanbag chairs, modular sofas, and decor items, is a must-visit for all Manhattanites looking to add a cozy touch to their homes.

As I planned to furnish my future apartment, I found myself at Lovesac, exploring their extensive range of products. Their staff, particularly Christian, was genuinely wonderful. He helped me create a personalized plan for my new place. He patiently explained every detail about their products and managed to sell me on it even though I wasn't able to purchase anything due to timing constraints.

This experience left me obsessed with Lovesac, and I can't wait to go back and furnish my new apartment. The personalized service, the quality of the products, and the overall friendly atmosphere make Lovesac a top choice for used furniture in Manhattan. So, if you're in the neighborhood, I highly recommend popping into Lovesac to find the perfect cozy addition to your home.

A Step Back in Time at Olde Good Things

Olde Good Things · 333 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store

After my visit to Beverly's Shop, I found myself drawn to another Manhattan gem - Olde Good Things. This place is a dream for any antique and history enthusiast. With its unbelievable collection of relics, it almost feels like stepping into a museum. But the best part? Everything is for sale!

My first visit to Olde Good Things was during an apartment renovation when I was on the hunt for some unique doorknobs. I ended up discovering a stunning collection of vintage art deco glass knobs that added the perfect touch of old-world charm to my space. I was hooked!

Since then, I've treated myself to several other pieces from their collection. From unusual finds to repurposed items and architectural salvage, this store truly has something for everyone. The thrill of the hunt in this store is unparalleled, as you never quite know what you might stumble upon.

What makes Olde Good Things truly stand out is their array of lighting fixtures. If only I had high ceilings, I'd have bought more than a few by now! Their hardware section is also noteworthy, offering a variety of knobs, hinges, face plates, and more. It's like an Aladdin's cave for anyone with an eye for detail and a love for the historic.

The staff at Olde Good Things are extremely accommodating and friendly. Their knowledge about the items in the store is impressive, and they always go out of their way to assist you. The prices are reasonable, especially considering the rarity and historical value of the pieces.

So, if you're in Manhattan and looking to add a touch of history to your home, do pay a visit to Olde Good Things. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

A Visit to SidebySide

SidebySide · 303 East 43rd Street, Suite PH, New York, NY 10017, United States
Antique furniture store

Picture this: a quaint store in the heart of the city, filled with an eclectic mix of furniture that feels like stepping into a treasure trove. That's SidebySide for you, a hidden gem in Manhattan that's a must-visit for anyone into unique and beautifully crafted furniture.

From the moment I walked into SidebySide, I was captivated by the wide variety of pieces on display. The collection seemed carefully curated, showcasing a range of styles that would suit any taste. I was particularly taken with a mid-century modern chair, its sleek lines and timeless design instantly catching my eye.

What really set SidebySide apart, however, was the level of service. The staff were knowledgeable and helpful, going the extra mile to ensure I had all the information I needed to make a decision. They patiently answered my questions and even offered suggestions based on my preferences.

My experience at SidebySide was truly memorable. It's not just a furniture store; it's a place where you can discover unique pieces and enjoy a shopping experience that's personal and enjoyable. If you're in Manhattan and looking for a place to find one-of-a-kind furniture, I highly recommend a visit to SidebySide. It's a shopping experience you won't soon forget.

Olde Good Things Antique Store

Olde Good Things Antique Store · 2420 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, United States
★★★★☆ · Antique store

Stepping into Olde Good Things Antique Store is like stepping into a treasure trove of history and elegance. As an architecture enthusiast, it's a joy to see an array of reclaimed building materials and antiques all in one place.

I remember standing in awe of the spectacular array of lighting and fixtures and wishing I had higher ceilings at home. Their collection of hardware, including vintage art deco glass doorknobs, adds a unique character to any room.

The thrill of the hunt here is unmatched. Olde Good Things salvages materials from buildings being demolished or refurbished, turning them into one-of-a-kind pieces.

I've had the pleasure of reorganizing my apartment with five different pieces of furniture from this store. Each piece, though not without its imperfections, added a distinct charm to my space.

The staff is always friendly and accommodating, adding to the overall pleasant shopping experience. And although their items weren't cheap, I found their prices to be very reasonable for the value and uniqueness they offer.

Even after furnishing my apartment, I still find myself drawn to this store, always on the lookout for the next unique find. If you're in Manhattan and have a love for antiques and salvaged items, I highly recommend a visit to Olde Good Things Antique Store.

A Blast from the Past at 20th Century by HKFA

20th Century by HKFA · 315 E 91st St, New York, NY 10128, United States
Antique store

Visiting 20th Century by HKFA is like stepping into a time machine. This place is not your typical used furniture store; it's a museum of sorts, a gateway to the past. It's not huge, but the wide variety of merchandise makes it feel like a sprawling labyrinth of treasures from bygone eras.

As I meandered through the store, I found myself constantly mesmerized by beautiful antique furniture, intriguing vintage jewelry, and, surprisingly, classic tools. Each item seemed to have a story, a past life that added to its charm.

The shopkeeper, Tony, was always friendly and willing to share the tales behind the trinkets, enhancing their appeal. His extensive knowledge of each item's history and its significance in the broader narrative of the 20th century made my visit to the store an educational experience as well.

On one of my visits, I fell in love with a pair of vintage lights. What made this purchase special was not just the lights themselves, but how they were presented. Tony took the time to share the backstory of these lights, adding a layer of significance to my purchase.

Every visit to 20th Century by HKFA feels like a treasure hunt. The reasonable prices and unique finds always keep me coming back. If you are looking for a place that offers more than just shopping, a place that offers an experience, I recommend you visit 20th Century by HKFA. It's a quaint oasis of the past in the heart of Manhattan.

A Mid-century Modern Haven at White Trash

White Trash · 304 E 5th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
★★★★☆ · Antique furniture store

As someone with an affection for mid-century design, my discovery of White Trash was nothing short of serendipitous. Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, this store is a treasure trove of unique and whimsical items, each piece reflecting the charm of the bygone era.

One of my most memorable finds was a LeRoy Neiman sketch that I spotted through the store window during one of my mid-COVID walks. I immediately inquired about it on their site. Within two days, Stuart, the affable store owner, had responded, and we smoothly completed the transaction. To my delight, he even personally delivered the sketch to my apartment on the Lower East Side.

Another time, I was on a quest for an authentic 18" walnut mid-century or Danish Modern style platter for my apartment revamp project. Stuart was so accommodating that he brought over a few platters for me to choose the best one for my purpose. The entire experience was such a breeze, and I couldn’t have been more satisfied.

In addition to the fantastic mid-century modern furniture, White Trash also boasts an array of whimsical gifts and lighting fixtures, all sold in their cozy digs. The rotating inventory ensures that you'll stumble upon something new and exciting with every visit. So, if you're someone with a penchant for mid-century design or simply looking for unique items to spruce up your space, do give White Trash a visit. It's truly a mid-century modern haven in the heart of Manhattan.


The quest for second-hand furniture in Manhattan is not just a shopping trip, but an adventure in and of itself. Each store is a treasure trove of unique pieces, each with its own story to tell.

Whether you're drawn to the sleek lines of mid-century modern design or the rustic charm of vintage pieces, Manhattan's used furniture stores have something for every style and budget. So why wait?

Embark on your furniture hunting adventure today and transform your living space into a reflection of your unique personality and style. Happy shopping!