8 Best Used Furniture Stores in Islip, NY

Aug 22, 2023
10 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Islip, NY

The hunt for quality used furniture can often feel like a treasure hunt, and in Islip, NY, it's no different. In this bustling town, you'll find a variety of used furniture stores that offer a wide range of options, from vintage antiques to contemporary pieces, and everything in between.

Whether you're new to the area or a long-time resident looking to spruce up your space, this guide to the best used furniture stores in Islip, NY, will surely come in handy. Let's embark on this journey together and uncover the hidden gems of Islip's second-hand furniture scene.

A Trip Down Memory Lane at Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center

REMEMBER YESTERYEARS VINTAGE CENTER · 901 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store

There's no place that evokes a sense of nostalgia quite like Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center. Every visit feels like a treasure hunt, and I inevitably stumble upon a gem every time I go. The inventory changes regularly, ensuring that every walk-through is an exciting exploration.

The store boasts an enormous variety of items, both old and new. On a recent visit, I was thrilled to find out that they also stocked Dixie Belle paint, a must-have for any DIY enthusiast. It's so much fun to choose a piece of furniture and then pick up all the paint and supplies needed to give it a fresh, personalized look.

The staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. During my visits, Joe and Bob always take the time to explain the constant turnover of items, making each trip feel like a new adventure. They create a welcoming atmosphere that makes you want to linger and explore all the fantastic items on offer.

But the experience doesn't end at the store. There are great eating places nearby, perfect for a post-shopping meal or snack. Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center is more than just a shopping destination, it's a delightful experience that keeps me coming back for more.

A Hidden Gem: Baraka Living Furniture

Baraka Living Furniture · 1440 Church St, Bohemia, NY 11716, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

One of my favorite spots to shop for quality furniture in Islip is Baraka Living Furniture. It's not just a furniture store; it's a treasure trove of unique, quality items at discounted prices.

On my first visit, I was taken aback by their extensive inventory. I was on the hunt for a new living room set, and the options at Baraka were simply overwhelming. But the super-friendly owner was there to guide me. He not only helped me find the perfect set but also ensured I didn't break the bank. Such superb customer service is indeed a rarity these days.

My subsequent visits to the store were equally delightful. I always find something new and interesting every time I browse their collections. I've gotten many compliments on the furniture I've purchased from Baraka, and I can't wait to go back for more.

But a word of advice: check their store hours before planning your visit. I once showed up a little late, and they had closed for the day. But trust me, a trip to Baraka Living Furniture is worth every minute. If you're looking for quality furniture in Islip at an affordable price, this is the place to go.

Discover the Professional Elegance of Corporate Office Furniture

Corporate Office Furniture · 2950 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Bohemia, NY 11716, United States
★★★★★ · Office furniture store

A trip to Corporate Office Furniture in Islip is like stepping into a world of sleek design, comfort, and productivity. Over the years, I've had the pleasure of purchasing office furniture from this store many times for different workspaces, and each experience has been nothing short of excellent.

Dave, one of their office designers, is incredibly knowledgeable and has a knack for providing illustrative designs promptly. On one occasion, his expert advice led me to change a few models I was contemplating, resulting in a significant saving of over $6,000 on my workstations.

The quality of their furniture is top-notch, priced reasonably, and what's more, they always deliver on time. From desks to chairs and everything in between, each piece I've bought from this store has enhanced the professional ambiance of my workspace.

Beyond selling furniture, the team at Corporate Office Furniture goes above and beyond to ensure a smooth and satisfying customer experience. Their reliability, helpfulness, and professionalism have made me a loyal customer, and I plan to continue purchasing from them in the future.

If you're in Islip and looking to furnish your office with high-quality, reasonably priced furniture, I highly recommend paying a visit to Corporate Office Furniture.

A Shopping Delight at Jennifer Furniture

Jennifer Furniture · 700 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Patchogue, NY 11772, United States
★★★★☆ · Furniture store

After a successful trip to Corporate Office Furniture, I decided to venture into the world of home furnishings at Jennifer Furniture. I was immediately greeted by Mario, a salesman with a keen eye for style and design. Mario was a breath of fresh air, completely devoid of the pushy sales tactics that have become all too common in many furniture stores. His knowledge and expertise helped me navigate the store's vast selection effortlessly.

One of my most memorable experiences at Jennifer Furniture was when I spotted a love seat in an ad. The low price listed made me skeptical, but I decided to visit the store anyway. To my surprise, not only was the love seat available, it was even more beautiful than in the ad! The entire buying process was seamless, and the love seat was delivered to my home the very next day by an efficient team. It genuinely felt like I had won a lottery!

Another pleasant surprise was my interaction with Danuta, a sales lady at the store. She was friendly, knowledgeable, and always available for questions, yet she never made me feel pressured. She gave me the space to explore the store at my own pace, and when I was ready, she finalized my purchase quickly and effortlessly.

Jennifer Furniture is a gem in Islip. The quality of their furniture, paired with their excellent customer service, makes it my go-to place for home furniture shopping. If you're in the area, I highly recommend checking it out!

Elegant Furnishings at Marc Williams Furniture

Marc Williams Furniture · 66 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, United States
★★★★★ · Furniture store

After a rewarding trip to Big Lots, I decided to switch gears slightly and take a look at the more upscale end of the furniture spectrum. That's how I found myself at Marc Williams Furniture, a local gem that offers a curated selection of high-quality pieces.

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and knowledgeable staff member named Bill. He was attentive and quickly understood what I was looking for. Bill helped me find a chair that not only fit perfectly in my small space but also matched my taste perfectly. His service was personalized and insightful from beginning to end, which made shopping at Marc Williams Furniture a pleasure.

While exploring the store, I was impressed with the quality and design of the furniture. I even splurged on a high-end sectional sofa that added a touch of luxury to my living room. Although the sofa had a slight crease on arrival, Bill explained that this was normal due to the fabric and it didn't take away from the overall aesthetics of the piece.

In addition to furniture, I also found a beautiful carpet that complemented my new sofa. The wait was a bit longer than initially expected, but it was worth it. The quality and design were unmatched, and it was clear that Marc Williams Furniture prided itself on offering top-notch products.

My experience shopping at Marc Williams Furniture was delightful. The quality of their products, combined with the excellent customer service, made for a satisfying shopping experience. If you're in Islip and in the market for upscale, tasteful furniture, I highly recommend visiting Marc Williams Furniture.

A Nostalgic Journey at Antiques With A Modern Edge NY

Antiques With A Modern Edge NY · 263 NY-27A, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
★★★☆☆ · Antique furniture store

My heart always skips a beat each time I pass by Antiques With A Modern Edge NY, a place that was once a sanctuary for antiquity lovers like me. Every visit to this store felt like a journey back in time, where each antique piece told a story of its own. The store might have given way to a new business now, but the memories of its unique charm are still fresh in my mind.

The eclectic selection at Antiques With A Modern Edge NY was always a sight to behold. I remember the great deals I scored on a beautiful bedroom set. The pieces were not only antique but they also had a modern edge, just as the store's name implies. They added a unique character to my home that I always receive compliments for.

While the store may no longer be in operation, it has left behind a legacy that still resonates with antique aficionados like me. The absence of such antique stores in the neighborhood is deeply felt, especially when the alternatives are the impersonal big box furniture stores. The charm of such locally owned businesses is truly irreplaceable.

A Timeless Shopping Experience at The Vintage Shoppe

The Vintage Shoppe · 284 Orinoco Dr, Brightwaters, NY 11718, United States
★★★★★ · Antique store

Stepping into The Vintage Shoppe in Islip is like stepping back in time. The moment I walked in, I was immediately welcomed by the fabulous owner and surrounded by a beautiful array of antique items. The atmosphere is warm and nostalgic, making it feel more like a treasure hunt than a shopping trip.

Every piece in the shop is carefully curated, and it is clear that the owner takes immense pride in her collection. Her enthusiasm is infectious and makes the shopping experience even more enjoyable. I've found myself losing track of time as I peruse the shelves, each filled with stunning items from yesteryears.

One of the things that truly stands out about The Vintage Shoppe is the pricing. The items, which range from furniture to knick-knacks, are all reasonably priced. This, combined with the owner's openness to friendly negotiation, is a refreshing departure from the impersonal, fixed-price shopping experiences that have become the norm.

I have made numerous purchases from The Vintage Shoppe, each one an absolute gem. The joy of bringing home a piece of history, a tangible connection to the past, is truly unparalleled.

If you're in Islip and have a penchant for all things vintage, I highly recommend paying a visit to The Vintage Shoppe. Each visit is a new adventure, and you never know what treasures you might uncover.

J & J Woodworking & Furniture Service Inc

J & J Woodworking & Furniture Service Inc · 21 Dunn Ct, Sayville, NY 11782, United States
Furniture store

The moment I walked into J & J Woodworking & Furniture Service Inc, I was immediately struck by the warm, inviting ambiance. This isn't your run-of-the-mill shop; it's a treasure trove of carefully crafted pieces, each with its own story to tell.

I was particularly drawn to a vintage dining table set with six chairs, love at first sight indeed! But, as luck would have it, the set was too big for my trunk. However, the amazing staff, without hesitation, offered to deliver it themselves, which they did, right on time the next day.

The entire experience at J & J Woodworking & Furniture Service Inc was incredibly convenient, not least because of the various payment methods they offer. But what truly sets this place apart is its commitment to customer service.

Every interaction felt personal and genuine, making it clear that this is more than just a business; it's a labor of love. So, if you're in the market for unique, quality furniture and appreciate excellent service, I highly recommend J & J Woodworking & Furniture Service Inc. It's truly a gem in Islip.


And there you have it! A comprehensive tour through the best used furniture stores in Islip, NY. Each store has its own unique charm, and all offer an array of enticing pieces sure to add a touch of character to your home.

Whether you're searching for that vintage centerpiece or a functional piece with history, these stores have got you covered. So why wait? Start exploring these treasure troves and let the thrill of the hunt lead you to your next favorite piece of furniture. Happy shopping!