Used Furniture Stores

10 Best Used Furniture Stores in Indianapolis, IN

Aug 3, 2023
12 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Indianapolis, IN

Welcome to the ultimate guide to finding the best used furniture stores in Indianapolis, IN. As an avid furniture hunter and local resident, I've spent countless hours exploring these treasure troves, hunting for unique pieces that add character and charm to my home.

Let me take you on a tour of my favorite spots where you can find high-quality, budget-friendly furniture that tells a story. From Goodwill Store's unexpected finds to the classy selection at Consigned by Design, there's a store for every style and budget. Get ready to be inspired and set out on your own furniture hunting adventure in Indianapolis!

This article compiles the shared experiences and reviews of our readers who have had encounters with various used furniture stores in the city. While it highlights some of the top-rated stores based on our readers' personal experiences, it's important to remember that this list is not exhaustive. There is a wealth of used furniture stores in the city that haven't been featured but are certainly worth exploring. We encourage you to use this article as a starting point, and to venture out and discover the many other excellent options available to you!

A Family Affair at S&S Furniture

S&S Furniture Β· 4830 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Furniture store

There's nothing like the warm and welcoming atmosphere of a family-run business, and S&S Furniture in Indianapolis is no exception. From the moment I stepped foot into their store, I felt like I was part of the family. The staff at S&S Furniture are genuinely friendly and helpful. They create a relaxed shopping environment where there's no pressure to buy, which made my shopping experience enjoyable and stress-free.

What struck me most about S&S Furniture is their commitment to customer satisfaction. They offer new furniture at discounted prices, making it an affordable option for everyone. Even if they don't have what you're looking for in stock, the staff go out of their way to assist you, demonstrating their focus on customer service.

The best part? The guys who delivered my furniture were fantastic. They were efficient, respectful, and ensured that my new pieces were perfectly placed in my home. I appreciated their professionalism and dedication to their work.

S&S Furniture is the epitome of a business that values its customers and strives to provide quality products at affordable prices. If you're in Indianapolis and looking for furniture, I highly recommend visiting S&S Furniture, you won't be disappointed!

Discovering Always Buying Furniture

Always Buying Furniture Β· 59 N 2nd Ave, Beech Grove, IN 46107, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜†β˜† Β· Used furniture store

During one of my strolls through the city, I stumbled upon a place called Always Buying Furniture. Intrigued by the name, I decided to check it out.

Stepping inside, I was pleasantly surprised by the great prices on everything I saw. I found a lovely coffee table that was just perfect for my living room. It was an absolute bargain, and I couldn't resist snagging it right away. As I browsed through the store, I noticed that each piece had its unique charm and style, making it a worthwhile experience for any furniture enthusiast like me.

However, it's essential to verify the store's current status before visiting, as some customers have mentioned that the place may no longer be operational. Always ensure you call ahead or check the latest reviews to avoid any disappointment.

My trip to Always Buying Furniture turned out to be a fantastic find, and I would recommend any fellow furniture lover in Indianapolis to give it a try. You never know, you might just stumble upon a treasure!


FURNITURE HOUSE I INC Β· 10202 E Washington St Suite 300, Indianapolis, IN 46229, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Furniture store

A trip to Indianapolis wouldn't be complete without a visit to FURNITURE CORNER. My fiancΓ© and I had heard good things about this store and decided to give it a try. The moment we stepped in, we were greeted by a sweet associate named Maria who was incredibly helpful throughout our visit.

We bought a living room set, a bedroom set, and two beds. Although it took a few months for our furniture to arrive, we were understanding given the current situation. Each piece was worth the wait, boasting its unique touch and comfort.

However, despite the few hitches with the delivery and adjustments needed for one of the beds, the team was very accommodating. They were willing to return and fix the issues, ensuring we were completely satisfied with our purchase.

The highlight of our visit was the impeccable customer service provided by Ricky and Kelsee. Their warm smiles and high-spirited conversations made the shopping experience all the more enjoyable. Their friendliness and professionalism were exceptional, convincing us to recommend the store to our family and friends.

In the end, we walked out with a beautiful living room set that was quite a steal. Though we had a few other items catching our eye, we decided to save them for our next visit. And yes, we will definitely be back! So, if you're in Indianapolis and in need of good-quality furniture, FURNITURE CORNER is the place to be!

A Hidden Gem: J and J Treasure Trove

J and J Treasure Trove Β· 3535 S Emerson Ave suite 323, Beech Grove, IN 46107, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

Oh, what a find J and J Treasure Trove is! One day, I was in search of a recliner for my living room. I had my eyes on an Abbyson recliner, but the retail price of $699 was a bit steep for me. Imagine my thrill when I found the very same recliner at J and J Treasure Trove for only $199! The same day delivery for an additional $50 was the cherry on top.

On another visit, I was greeted by Jeff, who was an absolute pleasure to do business with. I had been dreaming of a gray sectional for my living room, and there it was, in J and J Treasure Trove, priced at an affordable $950. Jeff let me mosey around the store and check out the sectional without any pressure or pushy sales tactics. I walked out 15 minutes later, a proud owner of my dream piece of furniture.

But the most unforgettable experience was when I saw a patio table on Marketplace. I asked them to hold it for me while I traveled from Lafayette to pick it up. Upon reaching the store, I found out that another customer had claimed the table pretending to be me.

The owner, though shocked and upset, made an unexpected offer. She gave me a bigger and better patio table for just $20 more. I love my new table, it seats more people than the previous one.

Every visit to J and J Treasure Trove leaves me with beautiful items, great prices, and the warm smiles of friendly people. This is one store in Indianapolis you should definitely check out before purchasing new furniture elsewhere. You might just save yourself a fortune!

4YourHome Furniture

4YourHome Furniture Β· 9513 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜†β˜† Β· Furniture store

Stepping into 4YourHome Furniture is like walking into an Aladdin's cave of furniture. I was immediately struck by the clean, organized layout of the store, making it easy for me to navigate through the variety of items on display. The staff was friendly and welcoming, ready to assist me with any queries but also giving me ample space to browse at my leisure, a balance I greatly appreciate while shopping.

My eyes were drawn to a pair of counter chairs that were just perfect for my kitchen island. Not only were they stylish and comfortable, but the prices were incredibly reasonable too. I was thrilled to make them mine and they've since become a favorite spot for morning coffee in my home.

I also remember purchasing a dryer from 4YourHome Furniture. The entire process was smooth and efficient, from the point of purchase to delivery and installation. Their customer service was commendable, and the dryer works marvelously. It was an experience that left me satisfied and eager to return for more.

As a frequent shopper, I've noticed that the store has undergone some changes under new management, and I must say, the place has only improved. It's become even nicer on the inside, and the staff has remained just as great. As someone who values good service and quality products, I know I'll keep shopping at 4YourHome Furniture.

JBP Furnishings

JBP Furnishings Β· 2740 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

My next stop was JBP Furnishings. Sometimes the best treasures are found in the least expected places. This was certainly the case with JBP. Not only did I find a beautiful, all cherry wood dresser for only $80, but the store also offers amazing new furniture as well. I was thrilled to learn about their huge warehouse full of new furniture, available at a fraction of the price of big box furniture stores.

The best part about JBP Furnishings is the feeling of family. It's family-owned, and they really treat you like you're part of it. I was looking for a specific piece of furniture and they were more than helpful. The staff didn't just point me in the right direction, they walked me through their collection until we found the perfect match.

What's more, I could take home the furniture almost immediately, no frustrating 8-12 week waits like other stores. The cherry on top? The owners are some of the nicest people I've ever met. I can't recommend this store enough. If there's something you want and they don't have it on site, just ask them about their warehouse. I guarantee you'll find what you're looking for. I've never been this impressed with a company in so long, so trust me when I say, you need to check out JBP Furnishings.

A Visit to Furniture Expressions

Furniture Expressions Β· 3015 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Furniture store

Indianapolis has a handful of great furniture stores, and Furniture Expressions is one of them. The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the friendliness of the staff. They were awesome and seemed genuinely interested in helping me find what I needed.

The store was filled with quality furniture pieces that were offered at prices that gave great value for money. I remember feeling a sense of satisfaction knowing that I was not just buying furniture, but investment pieces that would last a long time.

I would recommend Furniture Expressions to anyone looking for a great furniture shopping experience in Indianapolis. The combination of helpful staff and high-quality, affordable furniture is hard to beat.

Unearthing Hidden Gems at Salvage & Co Indy

Salvage & Co Indy Β· 6565 Coffman Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Furniture store

As a thrifty shopper, I always find myself drawn to the allure of Salvage & Co Indy, a place where one can find unique furniture pieces at deep discounts. It feels like a thrilling game of treasure hunt each time I step through its doors.

During one of my visits, I picked up a dresser that was a perfect fit for my bedroom. When I got home and started setting it up, I found out it was missing a leg. Initially, I was disappointed, but to my relief, the customer service rep was extremely understanding.

They emailed me back promptly, explained where it was actually listed that the dresser was missing a leg, and provided a refund. Their thoughtful response truly impressed me.

I've made over 25 orders from Salvage & Co Indy, and there were only a couple of times when something was missing. But each time, they took back the product for store credit without any fuss. It's a great spot for those willing to read the descriptions carefully and take a tiny risk for some amazing deals. I can't wait to see what I'll discover on my next visit!

iFurnishings-Furniture Rentals and Sales

iFurnishings-Furniture Rentals and Sales Β· 9210 E 33rd St, Indianapolis, IN 46235, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture rental service

I remember the time I was in desperate need of a sectional and coffee table for my new home. I reached out to iFurnishings-Furniture Rentals and Sales and met the owner, Scott. He welcomed me into the store (just remember you need an appointment to get in) and offered delivery for a very small fee within a few days. The experience was smooth and the prices were excellent.

When my old furniture was hauled off to the junkyard after 25 years of service, I found myself in a predicament due to supply chain issues. I needed furniture to fill the gap until my new pieces arrived. Scott came to my rescue with his array of quality home furnishings. His son, who is part of the delivery team, was very friendly and delivered the furniture in good condition right on time.

The service didn't stop there. Scott's team also saved me hundreds of dollars by offering fantastic prices. Their quick delivery and professionalism is something I highly appreciate. I have been recommending iFurnishings-Furniture Rentals and Sales to all my friends and family in Indianapolis. I will definitely be returning for all my future furniture needs!

CORT Furniture Outlet

CORT Furniture Outlet Β· 4904 Century Plaza Rd Unit B, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Used furniture store

On one of my furniture shopping adventures, I stumbled upon a hidden gem - the CORT Furniture Outlet. From the moment I stepped foot in the door, I was greeted by friendly and welcoming staff members.

Their assistance was quick and informed, making my shopping experience a breeze. One staff member, Ken Kennedy, truly stood out. His dedication and willingness to go the extra mile made me feel valued as a customer. His service was so exceptional, I knew I'd become a repeat customer.

The outlet itself was a treasure trove of fantastic deals. I was astounded by the sheer variety and quality of the items available. The prices were incredibly affordable, making this outlet a perfect spot for anyone looking to furnish their home on a budget.

What stood out to me was not just the variety of furniture but the convenience of the location. The outlet had ample parking, and if you were to run out of space, you could park at the nearby Walmart. They also had restrooms available and a reasonable unloading time of about two hours.

In conclusion, my trip to the CORT Furniture Outlet was not just a shopping experience. It was a delightful adventure filled with great finds, excellent service, and even better deals. For anyone in Indianapolis looking for quality used furniture, I can't recommend this place enough.

Wrapping Up My Furniture Hunting Adventure in Indianapolis

Reflecting on my furniture hunting journey across Indianapolis, I can confidently say that the city is a goldmine for anyone seeking unique, affordable, and great-quality used furniture. Every store I visited offered a distinct and memorable shopping experience, each with its own set of treasures waiting to be discovered.

These stores, each with their unique charm and inventory, are a testament to the vibrant second-hand market in Indianapolis. Whether you're a seasoned thrift shopper or a beginner looking for a great deal, there is a store that caters to your preferences and needs.

From unique vintage finds at Goodwill Store to high-quality pieces at Resell Indy, and from the affordable treasures at S&S Furniture to the incredible deals at Stop N Shop, each store offers countless opportunities to find the perfect piece for your home.

As I conclude my furniture hunting trip in Indianapolis, I find myself not only with several great pieces of furniture but also with wonderful memories of the shopping adventures I had in each store.

If you're in Indianapolis and looking to furnish your home with unique and affordable pieces, don't hesitate to explore these incredible used furniture stores. I assure you, you're in for a fun and rewarding shopping experience!