Used Furniture Stores

10 Best Used Furniture Stores in Columbus, OH

Aug 3, 2023
13 min read
Best Used Furniture Stores in Columbus, OH

The vibrant city of Columbus, Ohio, is known for its bustling food scene, beautiful parks, and a rich tapestry of arts and culture. But did you know that it is also a treasure trove for unique, high-quality used furniture?

As a resident, I've had the pleasure of exploring various used furniture stores around town, each with its unique charm and an array of eclectic items that add personality and character to any living space.

From vintage pieces that transport you back in time to modern, stylish furnishings that fit contemporary homes, Columbus's used furniture market is a haven for design enthusiasts and bargain hunters alike. Get ready to embark on a delightful journey as we uncover the best used furniture stores in Columbus, Ohio.

This article compiles the shared experiences and reviews of our readers who have had encounters with various used furniture stores in the city. While it highlights some of the top-rated stores based on our readers' personal experiences, it's important to remember that this list is not exhaustive. There is a wealth of used furniture stores in the city that haven't been featured but are certainly worth exploring. We encourage you to use this article as a starting point, and to venture out and discover the many other excellent options available to you!

Show & Sell Merchandise

Show & Sell Merchandise Β· 5722 Emporium Square, Columbus, OH 43231, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

I'll never forget the day I first walked into Show & Sell Merchandise. Nestled on Morse Road, this store is a treasure trove of unique, quality items. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, a place where you can take your time to explore and find that perfect piece.

The store is not massive, but it's packed to the brim with a wide variety of merchandise. Antique furniture, lighting fixtures, and vintage jewelry, every nook and cranny is filled with objects that have stories to tell. I remember being particularly drawn to a vintage lamp that added a unique charm to my living room. The selection changes often, so there's always something new and exciting to discover.

What truly sets Show & Sell Merchandise apart, though, is the ownerβ€”let's call him Tony. Tony is always welcoming and friendly, eager to share the tales behind the items in his store. His knowledge and passion for his merchandise are evident, making every visit both educational and enjoyable.

Whether you're looking to add a unique piece to your collection or just enjoy a few moments of peaceful browsing, Show & Sell Merchandise is a place that never disappoints. It's a small oasis of charm and history right here in Columbus.

My Exceptional Experience at LOTH, Inc.

LOTH, Inc. Β· 855 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43215, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Office furniture store

I still remember the first time I walked into LOTH, Inc., a heaven for used furniture in Columbus. Their collection is not just furniture; it's a curation of exceptional designs. It's a place where every piece tells a story, and each one could be part of your home.

One of the things that struck me was the warm welcome I received from the employees. They were friendly and immediately made me feel at home. I got a sense that they genuinely cared about helping me find the right pieces for my home.

The showroom is one of the friendliest I've been to. It's clear that LOTH, Inc. has a vision for excellence. It's not just a matter of having great furniture; it’s about creating an atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable and excited to explore.

Another thing that stood out to me was the quality of their collection. They have some truly amazing pieces. I remember being particularly impressed by a Leap chair. It was not just comfortable, but also stylish and well-made. I was assured it was backed by a solid warranty, which was comforting to know.

LOTH, Inc. isn't just a used furniture store; it's a place where you can find high-quality, well-designed pieces that will add character and charm to your home. If you're in Columbus, do yourself a favor and pay them a visit. It's an experience you won't forget.

Prime Furniture

Prime Furniture Β· 5378 Roberts Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

After an unforgettable experience at LOTH, Inc., I decided to continue my Columbus furniture exploration, which led me to Prime Furniture. Trust me, the name does the place justice. It truly is prime in every sense of the word. The moment I walked in, I was warmly welcomed by the staff, who were incredibly helpful and eager to assist me in finding the perfect piece for my living room.

I was on a hunt for a "cloud" couch, something with depth and comfort for our family. Prime Furniture delivered on that and much more. The price was unbeatable, and the selection of brand name products was impressive. It was a struggle to decide what to take home with me!

Imagine my surprise when I found a better alternative to the cloud couch I initially wanted. The quality was unreal, and the price was a total steal. I was hesitant about making such a big purchase, but the staff at Prime Furniture made me feel comfortable every step of the way. They ensured I got the best price and even offered super-fast shipping, which was a pleasant surprise.

But the gem of my visit was Caleb. His service was the best I've ever experienced in any city. He was respectful, took pride in his work, and honored his word. Every time I visit Prime Furniture, I'll definitely be looking for Caleb.

If you're in Hilliard and need quality furniture, give Prime Furniture a visit. Their selection, prices, and customer service are second to none. I couldn't be happier with my experience, and I bet you'll feel the same.

A Hidden Gem: Mary Catherine's

Mary Catherine’s Β· 1130 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Antique store

Tucked away in the heart of the city, there's a charming little shop called Mary Catherine's that truly is a hidden gem. The moment you walk in, you're greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, thanks to the lovely staff. I remember the first time I visited, the owner, Melanie, was so kind and welcoming. She even gave me a discount on the products and a free signed book which was a pleasant surprise.

Mary Catherine's is more than just a store, it's a treasure trove of unique and fascinating items. Despite being a smaller shop, the variety is quite extensive. From vintage furniture to intricately designed accessories, there's something that would catch anyone's eye. And the best part? The prices are fair, making the shopping experience all the more enjoyable.

If you're in Columbus and you're on the hunt for some quality used furniture or some unique pieces to add to your collection, I highly recommend checking out Mary Catherine's. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

A Hidden Gem: The Furniture Vault

The Furniture Vault Β· 1271 Edgehill Rd Suite A, Columbus, OH 43212, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

A trip to The Furniture Vault in Columbus is like stepping into a treasure trove of high-quality, stylish furniture. From the moment you step into the showroom, it's obvious that every piece has been carefully selected. The hand-tied construction ensures that no matter what you choose, it's not going to sag or fall apart.

I remember the day I found the perfect sofa there. It was a beautiful Norwalk Ana sofa, handmade locally and so comfortable. You see, I've been on the hunt for a comfortable couch for a long time due to my back issues. The staff were fantastic, treated me with respect and consideration. They understood my needs and gave me excellent recommendations.

One of the best things about this place is the flexibility they offer. I was given the option to have 5 years of fabric protection and flexible payment options. And guess what? They delivered it too!

The Furniture Vault is more than just a furniture store. It's a place where you can find beautiful, durable, and reasonably priced pieces. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to answer any questions and offer helpful advice. It's a place that I can confidently recommend to anyone looking for top-notch furniture. The selection, quality, and customer service are all top-notch. I know I'll be back for my next furniture purchase.

A Vintage Paradise: Boomerang Room Vintage

Boomerang Room Vintage Β· 3274 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Antique furniture store

Step into a time machine at the Boomerang Room Vintage, a really unique vintage shop that specializes in treasures from the 50's - 70's. It was a delightful day when I walked in and immediately recognized a print of a special painting my grandma once had, it was as if I was back in her living room, staring at it in awe as a child. The nostalgia was overwhelming and comforting.

The selection is nothing short of a vintage lover's dream, with a range of items that could easily transform any space into a mid-century haven. The staff is friendly and helpful, adding to the overall warm atmosphere of the place. And the prices? They are just as great as the inventory, making it a perfect spot for anyone on a budget.

I can safely say that Boomerang Room Vintage has become one of my new favorite places in Columbus. Every visit is like a little adventure, never knowing what rare and beautiful items you might stumble upon. If you're ever in Columbus and have a soft spot for all things vintage, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to the Boomerang Room Vintage. Trust me, you won't regret it!

A Rare Find at Trove Warehouse

Trove Warehouse Β· 2325 Wood Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Furniture store

Stepping into Trove Warehouse is like embarking on a treasure hunt, where every find is unique and exciting. This family-owned outpost has made its name in Columbus with a rotating selection of rare and one-of-a-kind home furniture and accessories that are anything but ordinary.

I remember being drawn in by the variety of the collection. Trove Warehouse boasts an extensive selection of furniture, each piece unique in design and high in quality. It was a refreshing departure from the usual offerings at big box stores. If you're looking for something different and of excellent quality, this place is a must-visit.

The staff at Trove Warehouse were very friendly and helpful during my visit. They were keen to assist, sharing their knowledge about the different pieces and making suggestions based on my preferences. It's this level of service that sets them apart and keeps me coming back.

Overall, the Trove Warehouse offers a wonderful shopping experience for those seeking unique and quality pieces for their homes. It's not just a furniture store. It's a place where you can uncover hidden gems, each with a story to tell. So if you find yourself in Columbus, be sure to check out Trove Warehouse. You might just find that perfect piece you've been searching for!

Sweet Deals at Sugarman Office Furniture

Sugarman Office Furniture Β· 971 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Office furniture store

When I first stepped into Sugarman Office Furniture, I was immediately taken by their impressive selection of chairs. I was in need of a comfortable chair for my home office, and the attentive staff didn't disappoint. They provided me with a variety of value options to choose from, ensuring I found the perfect fit.

What stood out the most was their commitment to customer satisfaction. They assured me that they would be there to help adjust the fit if needed after the purchase. I felt a sense of care that I wouldn't have experienced in a big box store.

When I later needed a matching desk for my workspace, Chuck Sugarman, the owner, went the extra mile for me. He not only found the exact desk I was looking for, but also ensured that every piece matched perfectly, from the handles to the filing cabinet and drawers. Within a week, he had ordered the desk and had it installed in my office.

This level of personalized service made me realize the value of supporting a local business like Sugarman Office Furniture. I would highly recommend it to any small business owner in Columbus, OH, looking for quality office furniture and a team that truly cares about meeting your needs.

All-American Furniture

All-American Furniture Β· 635 Harrisburg Pike, Columbus, OH 43223, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜† Β· Used furniture store

After leaving Sugarman Office Furniture, I decided to continue my furniture hunt at All-American Furniture. What an incredible discovery! The store's vast collection of new and pre-owned items is always changing, with fresh inventory coming in daily.

The owner has an eye for quality items, and it's clear she takes pride in offering a wide range of options, from vintage and antique pieces to high-end furniture straight out of glossy magazines.

I was particularly impressed with their beautiful sectionals and the variety of chairs, tables, and couches. I found a stunning ottoman and a couple of art pieces that were just perfect for my living room. And the best part? They offer delivery! The delivery guys have been with the store for a long time, and they were incredibly helpful in setting up my new furniture.

I also appreciated the owner's policy of buying furniture. She was open to checking out a few items that I was considering selling. Make sure to call ahead to see if what you're looking for is in stock. And if you decide to stop by, tell her Teri Novack sent you. You won't regret it!

A Treasure Hunt at One More Time Etc

One More Time Etc Β· 1641 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, United States
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Β· Used furniture store

As soon as I walked into One More Time Etc, I was instantly captivated by the array of quality items and unique pieces. The huge selection is like a treasure trove waiting to be explored.

I recall one time when I found an incredible couch that instantly caught my eye. It was an amazing experience; the couch was not only stylish but also wonderfully comfortable. The price was just the cherry on top, making it an absolute steal!

The store owner, Dan, was an absolute delight to speak with. He was patient and took the time to explain everything about the couch. To my surprise, they even offered to deliver and assemble it for me. This level of customer service is just one of the many reasons why I keep coming back for more.

On another visit, I decided to explore their online selection and found a few items that piqued my interest. When I went to check them out in person, I was not disappointed. The items were just as beautiful as they appeared online, if not more.

I also had a chance to sell some of my own items here and it was a very positive experience. The staff were friendly, helpful, and made the selling process smooth and hassle-free. It’s a wonderful feeling knowing that the items you once loved will get a second chance in another home.

One More Time Etc is not just a store; it's a community of people who appreciate and understand the value of giving items a second life. I can't wait to go back and see what new treasures I can find!


After spending a day hopping from one used furniture store to another in Columbus, Ohio, I can confidently say that this city is a treasure trove for anyone looking to find unique, high-quality items without breaking the bank. The variety of stores, each with its distinctive vibe and selection, offers an adventure that's as enjoyable as it is rewarding.

Whether you're a seasoned thrifter with a keen eye for vintage gems, a budget-conscious individual looking to furnish your home, or an eco-conscious shopper aiming to reduce your carbon footprint, Columbus' used furniture scene is a goldmine.

From the quirky charm of Flower Child and the upscale finds at Grandview Mercantile, to the community-centric ethos of Furniture with a Heart Thrift Store, there's a store to cater to every taste and need.

The journey doesn't end here, though. With new items arriving at these stores daily, each visit promises new discoveries. So, whether you're a Columbus resident or a visitor, I highly recommend embarking on this sustainable shopping adventure. You never know what treasures you might find.